The Bloody Benders

SERIAL KILLER CLIPS

Original newspaper accounts of America’s most prolific murderers.

This episode, we’re looking at the legend of a Kansas family that killed at least 11 visitors to their roadhouse in the early 1870s. They aroused suspicion by choosing as a victim a well-known physician, whose family soon pulled out all stops in a search until they uncovered his body, along with 10 missing travelers, on the Bender property. The Bender Family was nowhere to be found, and never were. Sightings and even arrests were regular for many years, even into the next century, but the second act of this episode purports to tell the true story of what happened to the mass murdering hostelers.

Music by Chuck Wiggins.

The Murderpedia entery on the Bloody Benders has photos of the scene and drawings from newspapers.

Sources:

Lawrence_Daily_Journal_Fri__May_9__1873_ Lawrence_Daily_Journal_Sat__May_17__1873_ Lawrence_Daily_Journal_Sun__May_11__1873_ Lawrence_Daily_Journal_Thu__May_8__1873_ Lawrence_Daily_Journal_Wed__Aug_4__1880_

The_Leavenworth_Times_Sat__Aug_14__1880_

The Red Hand

YESTERDAY’S NEWS

August 6, 1887

Frantic screams in the night shatter the pastoral calm of the Bibb County, Georgia, countryside. By the time neighbors arrive, nine members of the family of Captain Richard Woolfolk lay in deadly repose, brutally slain by the savage blows of an ax. The only survivor, 27-year-old son Thomas Woolfolk, the black sheep of the family and perennial loser, says that he escaped the carnage by jumping through a bedroom window and running into the woods. Suspicious eyes immediately imagine a noose around the young man’s neck. Will the truth come out? Will young Woolfolk pay the ultimate price for a crime he did not commit?

1887 0808 house - Copy

1887 0808 thomas younger 1887 0808 thomas jail - Copy

Timeline of the Woolfolk Case

June 18, 1860

Thomas George Woolfolk is born in the Woolfolk family farmhouse west of Macon, in Bibb county, the third child and only son of Richard F. Woolfolk, of Macon, and Susan Moore Woolfolk, of Athens in Clarke county.  Shortly after his birth Tom Woolfolk’s mother dies and is buried under a holly bush planted less than a hundred feet from the Woolfolk farmhouse.

1860-1867

Tom Woolfolk resides in Athens, being raised in the care and custody of his deceased mother’s sister, aunt Fannie Moore Crane, who appears to have lived on either Pulaski St. or Prince Ave.  In 1867, on the remarriage of his father, Tom Woolfolk moves back to live with his father and new stepmother in the Woolfolk family farmhouse in Bibb county.

June 1887

Tom Woolfolk pays the last of his many visits to Athens, staying with his Aunt Fannie.  His bizarre, insane behavior attracts attention.

August 6, 1887

In the early morning hours of this Saturday nine persons are slain with an ax in the Woolfolk family farmhouse near Macon.  The only inhabitant of the house not slain is Tom Woolfolk, who seeks help from a neighbor and claims to have struggled with unknown intruders and to have escaped alive only by jumping through a window.

The nine victims are: Richard F. Woolfolk, 54, Tom Woolfolk’s father; Mattie Woolfolk, 41, Richard’s wife and Tom Woolfolk’s stepmother; their six children (2 boys, 4 girls)–Richard, Jr., 20; Pearl, 17; Annie, 10; Rosebud, 7; Charlie, 5; and baby Mattie, 18 months old; and 84-year old Mrs. Temperance West, an aunt of Mrs. Woolfolk paying a visit.

The murder weapon, a short handled ax, smeared with hair and blood, is found in one of the rooms of the house.  Witnesses say they saw Tom Woolfolk making baskets with it the previous day.

An inquest is held at the scene of the crime.

Tom Woolfolk is arrested for murder and taken to the county jail in Macon.

August 7, 1887

The nine victims are buried in two rows (their graves later topped by red brick overlays) in Rose Hill Cemetery in Macon.    Sometime during this day the Woolfolk farmhouse well is dragged by the sheriff, and a bloody shirt and pair of drawers belonging to Tom Woolfolk are found.

December 1887

Indicted on nine counts of murder, Tom Woolfolk goes on trial for the murder of his father in Macon in the Superior Court of Bibb county.  His lead attorney is an Athens lawyer, John C. Rutherford.

February 10, 1888

After 12 minutes of deliberation, Tom Woolfolk is found guilty by the trial jury, and he is then sentenced to death by the judge.

February 11, 1889

The Georgia Supreme Court reverses Tom Woolfolk’s murder conviction and death sentence, giving as reasons: (1) the trial court had allowed the introduction of certain inadmissible incriminating evidence, and (2) certain courtroom spectators, referring to Tom Woolfolk, had angrily cried out, “Hang him! Hang him! Hang him!” during the prosecutor’s closing arguments, and the trial judge had done nothing.

June 3, 1889

Tom Woolfolk’s retrial for the murder of his father begins in the Superior Court of Houston county in Perry.

June 25, 1889

After 45 minutes of deliberation, the trial jury convicts Tom Woolfolk of murder, and he is again sentenced to death.

July 28, 1890

The Georgia Supreme Court affirms Tom Woolfolk’s murder conviction and death sentence.

October 29, 1890

At 1:30 p.m. on this Wednesday Tom Woolfolk is hanged in front of a crowd of 10,000 spectators in Perry.  The same day Tom’s body is buried in Orange Hill Cemetery in Hawkinsville in Pulaski county.

1898

Simon Cooper, son of London and Luana Cooper, black farmworkers who lived nearby, left Bibb County shortly after the Woolfolk Massacre. In 1898, Simon was lynched in Sommerville, South Carolina. On his body was found a notebook with the following lines: “Tom Woolfolk was mighty slick but I fixed him. I would have killed him with the rest of the damn family, but he was not at home.”

Source: “Remains of mass murder house found” by Donald E. Wilkes, Flagpole Magazine, February 12, 1997, via murderpedia.org and Murder by Gaslight.

Voluntary Pay:

Please consider supporting True Crime Historian by making a 99 cent donation, and receive a transcript of this podcast:

Newpaper sources for podcast:

 

1887 0807
The Atlanta Constitution, August 7, 1887
1887 0808
The Atlanta Constitution, August 8, 1887
Atlanta Constitution, October 30, 1890
Atlanta Constitution, October 30, 1890
St. Louis Post Dispatch, January 8, 1897
St. Louis Post Dispatch, January 8, 1897
Harrisburg (Pennsylvania) Daily Independent, January 9, 1897
Harrisburg (Pennsylvania) Daily Independent, January 9, 1897